Does Handmade Soap Contain Lye? The Truth About Sodium Hydroxide and Saponification
- charlenewalker1
- Jul 8
- 4 min read
I get this question often: "Does your handmade soap contain lye?"
The short answer? No, my finished cold-process soap doesn't contain lye. But here's where it gets interesting – it absolutely started with lye!
If you've ever wondered about the difference between handmade soap and commercial soap bars, or questioned whether natural soap making is safe, this guide will answer all your questions about lye and the saponification process.
What Is Lye and Why Is It Used in Soap Making?
Lye, chemically known as sodium hydroxide, is an essential ingredient in traditional soap making. Without lye, you simply cannot make real soap – it's impossible. But here's the key point: lye is used to make soap, not to be in soap.
Think of lye as the matchmaker in a beautiful chemical love story. When I create your beloved handmade soap, I carefully measure premium oils and butters, then introduce them to just the right amount of sodium hydroxide. What happens next is pure chemistry magic called saponification.

The Saponification Process: How Oils Transform Into Soap
During saponification, the lye and oils don't just mix – they completely transform each other. The sodium hydroxide breaks down the oil molecules and rebuilds them into something entirely new: soap and glycerin. By the time this chemical reaction is complete (which takes about 24-48 hours), the lye has done its job and disappeared entirely, leaving behind only nourishing, pure soap.
It's like baking a cake – you start with flour, eggs, and sugar, but the finished cake doesn't contain those individual ingredients anymore. They've transformed into something completely different and delicious!
Why Cold Process Soap Is Superior to Commercial Soap
This natural saponification process is what makes real handmade soap so special. Unlike synthetic detergents you'll find in most commercial soap bars, my cold process soap retains all the naturally occurring glycerin – that's what makes your skin feel so soft and moisturized after every wash.
Plus, I superfat my recipes, meaning I use slightly more oils than the lye can consume, ensuring some nourishing oils remain in the finished bar just for your skin. This is why artisan soap feels so luxurious and gentle compared to mass-produced alternatives.
The Science Behind Natural Soap Making
Here's what's actually happening during the saponification process:
Oils + Sodium Hydroxide + Time = Soap + Glycerin + No Lye
The chemical equation is more complex, but that's the beautiful simplicity of it. The lye doesn't just mix with the oils – it completely transforms them at a molecular level. By the time your handcrafted soap is ready to use, every molecule of sodium hydroxide has been converted into something else entirely.
Benefits of Handmade Soap vs. Commercial Soap
When you choose handmade soap over commercial alternatives, you're getting:
Natural glycerin that's retained in the soap (commercial manufacturers often remove this)
Superfatting that leaves nourishing oils on your skin
No harsh detergents that can strip your skin's natural oils
Quality ingredients chosen for their skin-loving properties
Traditional methods that create gentler, more moisturizing soap

Why I Choose Cold Process Soap Making
I could use other soap making methods and shortcuts, but I believe in the traditional cold process method because it gives me complete control over ingredients and creates the most nourishing bars possible. Every batch is carefully calculated to ensure complete saponification while leaving your skin feeling pampered, not stripped.
Common Myths About Lye in Soap
Myth: "Lye-free soap is better for sensitive skin" Truth: There's no such thing as soap without lye. What matters is proper saponification.
Myth: "You can make soap without lye" Truth: Without lye, you can only make detergent bars or melt-and-pour products.
Myth: "Lye makes soap harsh" Truth: Properly made soap contains no lye and is gentle on skin.
The Bottom Line: Is Handmade Soap Safe?
When you lather up with properly made handmade soap, you're experiencing the result of an ancient alchemical process that transforms simple ingredients into something that cleanses, nourishes, and pampers your skin – all without a trace of lye in sight.
This is the beauty of traditional soap making: science and art working together to create something that's both effective and gentle on your skin.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: How can I tell if soap still contains lye? A: Properly cured handmade soap won't contain lye. Reputable soap makers test their products and cure them appropriately.
Q: Is handmade soap better than store-bought? A: Handmade cold process soap retains natural glycerin and uses quality ingredients, making it more moisturizing than most commercial options.
Q: What's the difference between soap and detergent? A: Soap is made through saponification of oils and lye, while detergent is synthetically manufactured. Soap is generally gentler on skin.
Have more questions about natural soap making or handmade soap? I love hearing from my customers! Feel free to reach out anytime.
Love the skin 'ewe' are in!
Charlene
About Silly Bean Soap Co. Specializing in handcrafted, cold-process soap and skincare products made with nourishing sheep milk. Using traditional methods and premium ingredients, I create luxurious products that harness the natural moisturizing and gentle properties of sheep milk – perfect for sensitive skin and those seeking truly nourishing skincare. Where science meets suds, and sheep milk meets skin!
Comments